Liv Talley | NYC's Premier Dating Coach and LOVE QUEEN


Romantic Gestures: Signs of love or red flags?

Romantic gestures have long been celebrated as symbols of love and affection. But are they really signs of love…or is it possible they are secretly red flags you’ve been conditioned to fall for in place of true intimacy?

From grand displays like surprise trips and lavish gifts to simpler acts like writing love letters or planning a special dinner– these gestures are often seen as tangible “proof” of deep emotional connection. However, beneath the surface, these romantic actions often times serve as a facade: masking a person’s inability to connect emotionally on a more intimate level.

Understanding this paradox requires a closer examination of the psychology behind romantic gestures and the dynamics of emotional intimacy.

The Appeal of Romantic Gestures

Romantic gestures are universally appealing because they evoke strong emotional responses. They provide a sense of being valued, cherished, and loved, reinforcing the bond between partners. Psychologically, these gestures can trigger the release of oxytocin, often referred to as the “love hormone,” which fosters feelings of closeness and attachment. They can also serve as milestones in a relationship, creating shared memories that enhance a couple’s narrative of their partnership.

Watching men stand outside her window with a boombox and showering her with gifts after fights on screens has warped our sense of what true connection looks like. It has manipulated our feelings of intimacy to be tied to measurable images that we share online for the world to validate our relationship to us.

It has left us disconnected from ourselves. No longer turning inward to know if we love the person sitting across from us at a restaurant and instead, counting likes and comments on posts to decide if we’re truly in love.

Consequently, individuals might feel pressured to conform to these ideals, equating the frequency and grandeur of their gestures with the quality of their love.

And the notion of gestures = love is saturating viral videos online with the DEMAND that they be given without even conversations. Women stating online that “not settling” means finding a man who gives and plans and pays and doesn’t expect anything in return or even asks for her input.

OBVIOUSLY I’m not saying that romantic gestures are bad. I love the nights my husband brings home lilies or the earrings he bought me to congratulate me on my business milestone–but when they TAKE THE PLACE of deeper connection…they become problematic.

Hint: if you’re expecting him to mind-read in order to believe he loves you, you are not ready for an adult relationship.

When/why Gestures Mask Emotional Disconnect

Again, romantic gestures can indeed reflect genuine affection. However they can also be a coping mechanism for those who struggle with emotional intimacy. Here are several reasons why this paradox occurs:

1. Avoidance of Vulnerability: Emotional intimacy requires vulnerability, openness, and the willingness to share one’s inner world. For some, this level of openness is beyond their emotional maturity. For these individuals, romantic gestures can act as a shield, allowing them to express affection without exposing their deeper feelings and fears.

2. Compensation for Emotional Gaps: Those who are aware of their emotional shortcomings might attempt to mask with grand gestures. By doing so, they hope to distract from their inability to engage on a more intimate level. This can create a superficial sense of closeness, to hide underlying emotional gaps.

3. Fear of Rejection: Fears of rejection or inadequacy can lead people to rely on tangible expressions of love to protect themselves. By focusing on what they can do or give, they can more easily avoid the risk of emotional rejection. This behavior often stems from past experiences or deep-rooted insecurities.

Although not intentionally malicious, it is still a form of manipulation and something to be conscious of…

4. Cultural Conditioning: As mentioned earlier, societal norms play a significant role. Many are to believe that grand gestures are the ultimate proof of love, leading them to prioritize these actions over building a deeper emotional connection.

Just because he is bringing you flowers every week doesn’t mean you’re madly in love. Even if the flowers feel good…you need to be asking yourself if the connection itself feels good–independent of the flowers.

Make sense?

Recognizing the Signs of Emotional Disconnect

Identifying when romantic gestures are masking an emotional disconnect can be challenging but crucial for the health of a relationship.

Some signs to look out for include:

  • Lack of Deep Conversations: If conversations consistently remain on the surface level and avoid personal or vulnerable topics, it might indicate an emotional barrier.
  • Consistency of Gestures: While consistency in romantic gestures is often positive, an excessive reliance on them without corresponding emotional intimacy can be a red flag.
  • Emotional Unavailability: If one partner frequently seems emotionally distant or avoids discussing feelings, the gestures might be compensatory.
  • Transactional Nature: When romantic gestures feel transactional or like a substitute for resolving conflicts and addressing issues, it suggests a deeper problem.
  • Grandness of the Gesture: if the gestures are inconsistent with the commitment or healthy of the relationship, they may be “gifts of guilt” or attempts to keep you attached without actually giving you the safety you desire.

Beware of a FALSE SENSE of closeness. Women especially are manipulated into a “debt” dynamic with men who overcompensate with romantic gestures. When someone is constantly showering you with gifts and seemingly thoughtful situations, it can be easy to fall into feelings of obligation to someone who APPEARS to be giving you the “princess treatment.”

Remember that how your relationship looks to others doesn’t matter. You don’t need an IG worthy reel of your relationship for it to be right.

In fact, studies show that couples who post long, mushy posts about each other and all the overly-romantic things their S/O is doing for them (on a regular basis) are couples that are both unhappy and breakup. Because the psychology behind these types of posts are a search for external validation so that they can convince themselves to stay in the relationship.

Obviously, that doesn’t mean if you post about your partner you’re headed for divorce.

As with all romantic gestures, it’s important to look at the motivation behind it. Is it being shared for likes? Are you postulating?

Romantic gestures are GREAT additions to supplement healthy relationships. When they are meaningful and tailored to you, rather than doing what is done on tv to APPEAR romantic, these gestures can bring you closer as a couple.

Just be sure not to get swept up in the gestures IN PLACE of the person…check in with yourself regularly and ask yourself if you like the way the relationship makes you feel overall–not just when you’re being showered with gifts!

By fostering open communication and emotional vulnerability, couples can cultivate a genuine connection that transcends the allure of grand gestures, leading to a more fulfilling and emotionally intimate relationship that lasts.

What do you think? Do you love grand gestures or do they give you the ick?

Recommended Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • No products in the cart.